Search:

Type: Posts; User: Josiah; Keyword(s):

Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.09 seconds.

  1. Perhaps you didn't read by post. I never said...

    Perhaps you didn't read by post. I never said God changed His mind. And I specifically said that capital punishment is permissible and is NOT immoral or even wrong - just now imprudent. Paul's...
  2. EXCELLENT point, and ONE of the reasons why I...

    EXCELLENT point, and ONE of the reasons why I left the RC Denomination.

    We need to reject the individualism, egoism, appointments of SELF as the ONE interpreter of Scripture, the exemption of SELF...
  3. Replies
    328
    Views
    2,761

    Yes to Jesus and Paul. No to the Roman...

    Is that a yes or no?[/QUOTE]


    Yes to Jesus and Paul.

    No to the Roman Catholic/Zwinglian substitutions and denials.
  4. I AGREE with the RC Denomination's current "Pope"...

    I AGREE with the RC Denomination's current "Pope" on the matter of capitol punishment. While I agree it is morally PERMISSIBLE, I don't agree that it is any longer prudent. Indeed, in practice,...
  5. Replies
    328
    Views
    2,761

    Like modern Zwingians, the RCC dogmatically...

    Was Jesus using a figure of speech when he said, "...this is my body..."?

    [/QUOTE]

    Like modern Zwingians, the RCC dogmatically insists that what Jesus stated and Paul by divine inspiration...
  6. Replies
    328
    Views
    2,761

    NOT "... this has undergone an alchemic...

    NOT "... this has undergone an alchemic transubstantiation at the utterance of my words, changing from one reality to another foreign reality by that specific, physical means leaving behind an...
  7. Replies
    328
    Views
    2,761

    Where did Jesus say "changed?" "Converted?" ...

    Where did Jesus say "changed?" "Converted?" "Transformed?" "Alchemy?" "Transubstantiation?" "SEEMS like but isn't really?" "Is not?" "Aristotle?" "Accidents?"
  8. Replies
    73
    Views
    844

    He OPINIONATED.... and offered NOTHING -...

    He OPINIONATED.... and offered NOTHING - absolutely nothing whatsoever - to substantiate it. Nor have you.

    You just keep confirming that he gave NOTHING to support his opinion.




    That's...
  9. Replies
    73
    Views
    844

    Opinion = fact to you. At least when some...

    Opinion = fact to you. At least when some Catholic opinionates. My friend, you are simply proving my point: The opening post shares a personal OPINION with nothing - absolutely NOTHING - to...
  10. Replies
    36
    Views
    270

    You don't understand Catholicism. The RCC agrees...

    You don't understand Catholicism. The RCC agrees that Scripture is inerrant. It's just that it itself INSISTS that IT itself individually is inerrant, too. Thus, for Scripture to be correct,...
  11. Replies
    328
    Views
    2,761

    Will you do this? Copy/paste the verbatim words...

    Will you do this? Copy/paste the verbatim words of John, Chapter 6. Then enbolden and underline each of these words essential for the support of the new, unique, Eucharistic Dogma of the singular...
  12. Replies
    73
    Views
    844

    He OPINIONATED.... with NO even attempt to...

    He OPINIONATED.... with NO even attempt to substantiate such as true. No history, no anything. Truth is often irrelevant to Catholics.





    .
  13. Replies
    139
    Views
    1,354

    My personal, fallible OPINION is - yes, probably....

    My personal, fallible OPINION is - yes, probably. And I note that IS the historic and (until quite recently) ecumenical interpretation. But since the context is not Baptism (and Jesus' unique form...
  14. Replies
    73
    Views
    844

    Chesterton substantiated NOTHING from history.......

    Chesterton substantiated NOTHING from history.... or anything else, for that matter. Yes, he gave an entirely unsubstantiated OPINION - as egotistical and divisive as it is - and seemed to have...
  15. Replies
    552
    Views
    6,075

    1. You are wrong about Luther. 2. We all...

    1. You are wrong about Luther.

    2. We all know that modern Catholicism rejects the view of Jesus as the Savior, and thus rejects SOLA Gratia - SOLUS Christus - SOLA Fide; the error is in looking...
  16. Replies
    552
    Views
    6,075

    Maggie, answer this: WHO is the Savior? ...

    Maggie, answer this:

    WHO is the Savior?


    IF you answer "Jesus" then Jesus is the Savior. Not you - not a bit, not at all, not now, not ever, not in any way or shape or form or manner....
  17. Replies
    552
    Views
    6,075

    All the apostles are dead. The RCC...

    All the apostles are dead.

    The RCC acknowledges only one authoritative, authoritarian teacher: ITSELF CCC 87, etc.
  18. Replies
    552
    Views
    6,075

    "Grace" we were all taught by our Catholic...

    "Grace" we were all taught by our Catholic teachers, is HELP. This, verbatim, is what we were taught at my parish: "Grace is like the gas God puts in YOUR tank so that YOU can get YOURSELF where YOU...
  19. Replies
    272
    Views
    3,564

    The RCC condemns, ridicules and rebukes any that...

    The RCC condemns, ridicules and rebukes any that insists that self is the sole, individual, authoritative, unaccountable interpreter of Scripture. It designates itself as the sole, individual,...
  20. Replies
    73
    Views
    844

    A personal and entirely unfounded OPINION........

    A personal and entirely unfounded OPINION..... without a shred of anything (but unanswered questions) to support it. What I "take" from this is something I often find in Catholicism: a lack of...
  21. Replies
    552
    Views
    6,075

    The RCC recognizes one authorative teacher: IT...

    The RCC recognizes one authorative teacher: IT ITSELF. And it itself declares that when it itself exclusively speaks, ergo God Himself is. CCC 87. It's the same in those groups regarded as...
  22. Replies
    552
    Views
    6,075

    If the Protestant insistence that Jesus is the...

    I have said many times the bible does not anywhere teach the doctrine of faith alone.

    What I have said though is that we are not as far apart as we think in practice.


    [/quote]


    If the...
  23. Replies
    552
    Views
    6,075

    If Maggie40 is right and what Protestants...

    If Maggie40 is right and what Protestants typically embrace and what Luther taught in justification (narrow): Sola Gratia - Solus Christus - Sola Fide is RIGHT, then Maggie40 is - at the very least -...
  24. Replies
    27
    Views
    444

    If SELF is the Savior, yes - one needs to define...

    If SELF is the Savior, yes - one needs to define what THEY do that merits heaven.

    PROTESTANTS typically believe that faith is a gift of God.... GOD gives us faith, thus it is not OUR work, it is...
  25. Replies
    552
    Views
    6,075

    SOME Catholics rebuke Catholicism in...

    You could not possibly be more spot on correct. I am not convinced that Maggie understands Protestantism or Catholicism [/QUOTE]


    SOME Catholics rebuke Catholicism in justification, insisting...
Results 1 to 25 of 500
Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4