Search:

Type: Posts; User: Josiah; Keyword(s):

Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.12 seconds.

  1. Take note: No Catholic here is answering or even...

    Take note: No Catholic here is answering or even responding to the question: TRANSUBSTANTIATION. I think some Catholics WISH the RCC's dogma was like the unofficial, nondoctrinal view of the EOC -...
  2. It is incorrect. Lutherans reject ALL the...

    It is incorrect. Lutherans reject ALL the theories invented by those western, medieval, RCC "Scholastics" - including both Transubstantiation and consubstantiation.



    Here is the Lutheran...
  3. So, you can't? Or won't? .

    So, you can't? Or won't?





    .
  4. I COMPLETELY agree! It's one of the reasons I...

    I COMPLETELY agree! It's one of the reasons I left your denomination.

    But this thread is about TRANSUBSTANTIATION. The new, unique, Eucharistist dogma of the RCC.
  5. Entirely avoided the entire question and the...

    Entirely avoided the entire question and the whole Dogma...




    .
  6. No. The dogma is TRANSUBSTANTIATION. The...

    No. The dogma is TRANSUBSTANTIATION.
    The opening pastor asked, specifically, about TRANSUBSTANTIATION.
    The opening pastor asked about the new, unique RCC dogma, which is TRANSUBSTANTIATION. ...
  7. Just seems to me..... if someone asks about the...

    Just seems to me..... if someone asks about the 2014 Toyota Camry - and you answer about automobiles in general - you either don't know what a Toyota Camry is....OR (more likely) you are evading the...
  8. Your "SIMPLY..." is just your entire evasion,...

    Your "SIMPLY..." is just your entire evasion, avoidance... of the whole thing, the whole enchilada, the dogma.

    Can't blame you. I don't rebuke you (I'd do the same thing in your shoes)



    .
  9. Replies
    51
    Views
    431

    There is NOTHING in Exodus that confirms the new,...

    There is NOTHING in Exodus that confirms the new, unique, RCC Eucharistic Dogma of TRANSUBSTANTIATION/ACCIDENTS.
  10. You COMPLETELY avoided the whole dogma. ...

    You COMPLETELY avoided the whole dogma. Craftfully, I might add. Can't blame you.




    .
  11. Replies
    79
    Views
    752

    Lutheran, at times, DO refer to the service at...

    Lutheran, at times, DO refer to the service at "Mass."

    I think it TRAGIC that the RCC does so little to reach out to the TWO MILLION Catholics that historically immigrate into the USA every...
  12. Your craftfully evaded the ENTIRE dogma: ...

    Your craftfully evaded the ENTIRE dogma: TRANSUBSTANTIATION. You wholly evaded, avoided, circumvented the whole doctrine.

    Can't blame you. And I didn't rebuke you. In your shoes, I'd do...
  13. Please quote all the Eucharistic texts (include...

    Please quote all the Eucharistic texts (include John 6 if you must). Underline and embolden for us all each of the following words:

    CHANGE
    CONVERT
    BECOME
    FROM
    INTO
    ALCHEMY...
  14. Replies
    200
    Views
    2,415

    1. An embrace of accountability (the point which...

    1. An embrace of accountability (the point which the LDS, all 'cults' known to me, and the RCC - the objectors to Sola Scriptura) all disagree with us.

    2. It is the most sound, most reliable norm...
  15. Replies
    200
    Views
    2,415

    In RCC Fundamentalism and Totalitarianism (as in...

    At some point truth has to be acknowledged for what it is: "true truth". The problem with proclaiming truth is that the mind-set of many in our culture is that there is no such thing as objective...
  16. Thread: Welcome Home

    by Josiah
    Replies
    443
    Views
    4,150

    About HALF of the members of my Lutheran parish...

    About HALF of the members of my Lutheran parish are ex-Catholics.

    I doubt that HALF of the members of my Catholic parish were ex-Lutherans. In fact, I doubt if 10% were ex-Protestants, I'd guess...
  17. The RCC dogmatically abandoned that in 1551 when...

    The RCC dogmatically abandoned that in 1551 when it dogmatized alchemy's TRANSUBSTANTIATION instead.




    .
  18. YES! But your denomination dogmatically...

    YES! But your denomination dogmatically abandoned that in 1551, taking up alchemy's TRANSUBSTANTIATION instead.



    .
  19. The RCC created division by leaving Real Presence...

    The RCC created division by leaving Real Presence and dogmatizing this new, UNIQUE, RCC Eucharistic Dogma: TRANSUBSTANTIATION/ACCIDENTS.

    I agree, it's PRIDE of appointing self to dogmatically...
  20. It was CLOSE but no cigar. It was very...

    It was CLOSE but no cigar. It was very inaccurate and incomplete. Some lay Catholics like to do that.




    .
  21. When Christ entered Jerusalem on Palm Sunday, He...

    What change you ask? Well, in the Lutheran position the bread and the wine DO NOT CHANGE---what DOES change is that Christ is now present alongside the bread and the wine. This means NOTHING...
  22. The RCC changes what He revealed. He said "IS."...

    The RCC changes what He revealed. He said "IS." The verb means to be, to exist, real, present. If you look in any dictionary, you will not find this definition for the verb: Converted and/or...
  23. Replies
    200
    Views
    2,415

    Using Scripture as the rule in the norming of...

    Using Scripture as the rule in the norming of disputed doctrines among us is something we DO - a practice, praxis. It's not something believed - for salvation or for anything. Practices don't...
  24. What change? You didn't answer ANY of the...

    In the CATHOLIC position--the object of change

    [/QUOTE]


    What change?

    You didn't answer ANY of the questions that you quoted from me.
  25. Replies
    200
    Views
    2,415

    Read what you quoted. .

    No one does. A praxis is something DONE, not something BELIEVED.


    The Rule of Scripture in Norming (What Luther and Calvin called "Sola Scriptura")


    The Definition:


    The Rule of...
Results 1 to 25 of 500
Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4