Atheists just love peer reviews. If a "scholar" reviews something they like favorably, the "scholar" is an official peer.

stiggy wiggy said:
Something is peer reviewed if it is reviewed by a peer.

But what is a peer? According to Merriam Webster, a peer is:

"one that is of equal standing with another : EQUAL

especially : one belonging to the same societal group especially based on age, grade, or status"

But who reviews the "standing" to determine if there is "equality?" Second class peers? Peers, once removed?

What about "scholars?" What is a scholar, and what scholarly qualifications are required to designate one as a scholar? Are PHD's required?

Were Isaac Newton's discoveries peer reviewed? Were Paul's doctrines? Who were Paul's peers? John? Peter? Did Paul get Peter to review his doctrine about the acceptance of gentiles? No. Quite the opposite.

My favorite peer review is in Genesis 1:3-4:

3 "And God said, “Let there be light,” and there was light. 4 God saw that the light was good."

Here we see the mystery of the Trinity. God reviews His own work. The Father, Son and Holy Spirit are EQUAL.

Of course, He has no other peers.
Click to expand...

I noticed that you had a few naysayers, who tried making it easier to disregard the point of the op.
so, I decided to do some research on it.
I've found a number of different industry standards for peer-review qualifications.

CPA (honestly, i never would have considered that CPA's would actually have a peer review qualification standard, so needless to say.... i am impressed!)

How to become a Peer Reviewer

us.aicpa.org us.aicpa.org


Medical industry.



A general invitation? Higher Learning Commission.

www.hlcommission.org

Become a Peer Reviewer | Peer Review

Higher Learning Commission
www.hlcommission.org www.hlcommission.org

Taylor Francis Journal Editors.

Adobe Acrobat

acrobat.adobe.com acrobat.adobe.com

The Dept of Education has a standard.

Office of Postsecondary Education Peer Reviewers: Frequently Asked Questions

This page provides frequently asked questions and answers for current and potential grant application reviewers for Office of Postsecondary Education programs. It provides general information about the OPE peer reviewer process, links to program information, and the how to register Web site.
www2.ed.gov

Ok....
I'm stopping here because the list of qualifications for various industries is quite lengthy.

My search parameter was

"Peer review qualifications"

Suffice it to say that qualifications for peer review are pretty serious.
 
CrowCross said:
Yes, I'm shaking in my boots.

NEXT
Click to expand...
Why are you not properly investigating whether you have a point or not? You're strutting around here claiming victory because people like me who are not experts can't answer your question, but you won't ask it of those who can.
 
Whatsisface said:
Why are you not properly investigating whether you have a point or not? You're strutting around here claiming victory because people like me who are not experts can't answer your question, but you won't ask it of those who can.
Click to expand...
Victory....absolutely....as you STILL can't explain how an assembly line of organelle evolve...yet still have bad things to say about creation science.
 
CrowCross said:
Victory....absolutely....as you STILL can't explain how an assembly line of organelle evolve...yet still have bad things to say about creation science.
Click to expand...
Why are you changing the subject away from you asking your question of someone qualified to answer it?

By far the academic consensus is that evolution is true and for very good reasons, so I'll take the scientific point of view over yours that has no science behind it every time.
 
Whatsisface said:
Why are you changing the subject away from you asking your question of someone qualified to answer it?
Click to expand...
I have already answerd that question...why can't you recognize that fact????

This is a forum. An online forum....the problem is you are hiding behind some make believe scientist who you have FAITH in answering a question that you don't have the answer to.

Did you watch the videos I presented?
Whatsisface said:
By far the academic consensus is that evolution is true and for very good reasons, so I'll take the scientific point of view over yours that has no science behind it every time.
Click to expand...
A consensus doesn't make something true.

Once again, Did you watch the videos I presented?
 
CrowCross said:
I have already answerd that question...why can't you recognize that fact????

This is a forum. An online forum....the problem is you are hiding behind some make believe scientist who you have FAITH in answering a question that you don't have the answer to.

Did you watch the videos I presented?

A consensus doesn't make something true.

Once again, Did you watch the videos I presented?
Click to expand...
You answered my question vaguely, hardly satisfactorily.

I agree that a consensus on it's own doesn't make something true, but the reasons for the consensus can and in this case does.

You not wanting to take your question to academia is a blatant dodge on your part.
 
Whatsisface said:
You answered my question vaguely, hardly satisfactorily.

I agree that a consensus on it's own doesn't make something true, but the reasons for the consensus can and in this case does.

You not wanting to take your question to academia is a blatant dodge on your part.
Click to expand...
Considering that is your only response shows a Mr. Bojangles dance on your part.

have you watched the videos?
 
CrowCross said:
The "computer generated video" portrays the reality.....much like a computer generated video showed the landing of Martial rovers.
Click to expand...
Computer generated videos portrait whatever the creators of the video want. Have you ever watched a Pixar movie? Spoiler alert:They are no real.
 
CrowCross said:
Are you saying a motor protein walking across a microtubule doesn't exist???????
Click to expand...
No,. I am saying computer generated videos portrait whatever the creators of the video want. That is why I said "Computer generated videos portrait whatever the creators of the video want."
 
CrowCross said:
Considering that is your only response shows a Mr. Bojangles dance on your part.
Click to expand...
Of course it doesn't, because I admit I can't answer it because I don't have the expertise, so I suggest you ask it of those who do, and you're remarkably reluctant to do so. It's not hard to understand why.
CrowCross said:
have you watched the videos?
Click to expand...
Yes, but so what? Why are you asking me? I have admitted I don't have the expertise to address it. Why aren't you showing it to an expert to see what he/she will say?
 
The Pixie said:
No,. I am saying computer generated videos portrait whatever the creators of the video want. That is why I said "Computer generated videos portrait whatever the creators of the video want."
Click to expand...
Let me guess....next you'll be telling me the creator of the videos is making this stuff up.
 
CrowCross said:
lots of time they link you to a 100 page document and say.....the answer is in there, go read it.
The latest is telling me to go seek out and find an expert on the subject.....as if they'll have the answer.
Click to expand...
How would you know, if you don't ask. You're just making excuses though.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top