Did Jesus create the angels?

I

imJRR

Well-known member
Nathan P said:
He knew as the Word he had glory with the Father then. You are still failing to clearly document where there was a Son of God before the Word became flesh and can only find scriptures that you want them to infer them to what you want them to say?
Click to expand...

I didn't infer anything - Jesus said what He said. The Word = the Person of Jesus Christ.
 
I

imJRR

Well-known member
Continuing from the above: In John 17:5 (and 24), Jesus is speaking as both the Word and the Son, and that's because He is both and always has been. There's never been a time when the Father wasn't the Father; there's never been a time when the Son wasn't the Son. This is simply following the verse.
Hebrews 1:3 speaks of Jesus Christ - the Son - being the exact and/or perfect representation of the being and nature of God. Everything the Father is the Son is. One of those "everythings" is that the Father is eternal. Therefore so is the Son. You can't have an eternal Father without having an eternal Son. Again, that's simply following the verse.
 
S

shnarkle

Well-known member
Nathan P said:
The point you all still miss is if there was Son of God before the Word became flesh God would have surely documented it, like he did after the Word became flesh.
Click to expand...
It is documented. Christ says he is the Alpha and the Omega. He never says he began and ended. John says that: "in the beginning was the word". He didn't say, 'In the beginning was god". To say 'in the beginning was the word" is not the same as saying "the word began".

Logically, existence is necessarily eternal. To claim otherwise is to contradict oneself, e.g. existence doesn't exist. There can be no beginning or end to existence, only things can begin and end.
 
N

Nathan P

Well-known member
shnarkle said:
It is documented. Christ says he is the Alpha and the Omega. He never says he began and ended. John says that: "in the beginning was the word". He didn't say, 'In the beginning was god". To say 'in the beginning was the word" is not the same as saying "the word began".

Logically, existence is necessarily eternal. To claim otherwise is to contradict oneself, e.g. existence doesn't exist. There can be no beginning or end to existence, only things can begin and end.
Click to expand...
The Alpha and the Omega is not the same as the Son of God. You know there is nothing to document that there was a Son of God before the Word became flesh and you have to keep making scriptures say what they do not say.
 
S

shnarkle

Well-known member
Nathan P said:
The Alpha and the Omega is not the same as the Son of God.
Click to expand...
What essential or effective difference is there? Words emanate from God just like sons come from fathers.
Nathan P said:
You know there is nothing to document that there was a Son of God before the Word became flesh and you have to keep making scriptures say what they do not say.
Click to expand...
The metaphors used by Christ himself refute your baseless claims.
 
N

Nathan P

Well-known member
shnarkle said:
It is documented. Christ says he is the Alpha and the Omega. He never says he began and ended. John says that: "in the beginning was the word". He didn't say, 'In the beginning was god". To say 'in the beginning was the word" is not the same as saying "the word began".

Logically, existence is necessarily eternal. To claim otherwise is to contradict oneself, e.g. existence doesn't exist. There can be no beginning or end to existence, only things can begin and end.
Click to expand...
Who told John to write "in the beginning was the Word"?
 
N

Nathan P

Well-known member
shnarkle said:
I can see how this argument works with regards to Jesus because Jesus wasn't even named until eight days after he was born. However, God is unchanging so I don't see how he could become a father. The word is eternal, therefore he has always proceeded from the father. If not, then God spent eternity alone until he said his first word.
Click to expand...
We do not know what God did before 'in the beginning'. He could have other worlds so far out there that there is zero chance of any contact between civilizations.
 
N

Nathan P

Well-known member
shnarkle said:
And what is the point of this supposed point?

There is no "before" before the beginning, nor is there an "after" after the end.
Click to expand...
Yes there was time before the beginning because there are 3 heavens and only the heaven with the earth , stars etc., is in the first heaven and what is in the other 2 heavens we do not know, except that God resides in one of the .other 2.
 
S

shnarkle

Well-known member
Nathan P said:
Yes there was time before the beginning because there are 3 heavens and only the heaven with the earth , stars etc., is in the first heaven and what is in the other 2 heavens we do not know, except that God resides in one of the .other 2.
Click to expand...
Fallacy of Begging the Question. You're assuming that "in the beginning" isn't referring to the beginning at all. There's no reason to assume that. There is no such thing as time before the beginning of time, nor time after the end of time. Nothing exists outside of space either. These are blatant contradictions. Your arguments are incoherent and contradictory.
 
N

Nathan P

Well-known member
shnarkle said:
Fallacy of Begging the Question. You're assuming that "in the beginning" isn't referring to the beginning at all. There's no reason to assume that. There is no such thing as time before the beginning of time, nor time after the end of time. Nothing exists outside of space either. These are blatant contradictions. Your arguments are incoherent and contradictory.
Click to expand...
In the beginning means in the beginning and not before or after the time frame of in the beginning.
 
N

Nathan P

Well-known member
shnarkle said:
And what is the point of this supposed point?

There is no "before" before the beginning, nor is there an "after" after the end.
Click to expand...
The point is an angel told John information of what to write and only Jesus knew that information rev. 5: 1-10 or 11 and since only Jesus knew that information then the angel who told John that information had to have been Jesus.
 
JustTheFacts

JustTheFacts

Member
jamesh said:
According to jw.org Jesus did create the angels.
When Was Jesus Created, and Why Is He Called God’s Son?

When was Jesus created?​

"God created Jesus before creating Adam. In fact, God created Jesus and then used him to make everything else, including the angels. That is why the Bible calls Jesus “the firstborn of all creation” by God.—Read Colossians 1:15, 16.

Before he was born in Bethlehem, Jesus lived as a spirit creature in heaven. When the time came, God transferred Jesus’ life from heaven to Mary’s womb so that he could be born as a human.—Read Luke 1:30-32; John 6:38; 8:23."

But the Bible says that God created the angels. Nehemiah 9:6, "Thou ALONE art the Lord, Thou hast made the heavens, The heaven of the heavens with all their host. The earth and all that is on it, The seas and all that is in them, Thou dost give life to all of them And the heavenly host bows down before Thee."

So how can Jesus have created the angels since God says He created them? Moreover, we read from the Jw's above , "Jesus lived as a spirit creature in heaven." And who was that spirit creature? It was none other than Jesus as Michael the arc angel who God created. Also notice that the spirit creature Jesus who is also Michael had his life transferred into Mary's womb so that he could be born a human. How do the Jw's reconcile these "glaring" contradictions of the Bible?


In Him,
herman
Click to expand...
Simple!
Jehovah made all things...THROUGH>>>Jesus.
But, alas, Jesus HIMSELF is also an angel!

Mal 3:1- "Behold, I send my messenger to prepare the way before me,
and Jehovah whom you seek will suddenly come to his temple;
the ANGEL of the covenant in whom you delight, behold, he is coming,
says Jehovah of hosts.
2- But who can endure the day of his coming,
and who can stand when he appears?"

His Angel, John, prepared the way for Jehovah, who spoke and acted through his son- the
Greatest of ALL God's Messengers ('Angels').

1- An "angel" - is it as the churches portray?
Is it a species of winged creatures, or is it a POSITION?
The meaning of the word settles that: the role of a MESSENGER.
2- Show what "spirit" really refers to- again, NOT a specific creature, but the TYPE of being, or a power- such as God's POWER. For spirit means "breath, wind" denoting an unseen force. God is spirit (wind), so are Christ and his fellow messengers (angels)
3- Jesus had a name before being given the name "Jesus", and since Jesus has the position/voice authority of Archangel (1 Thess 4)- we all know what name THAT was!
4- Christ & Michael lead God's people and carry out the same works (Daniel/Revelation}
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top