Do you think all Christians who encounter and try to talk to atheists regarding the idea that Jesus died and rose again to give them eternal life will invariably leave them with the same impression?
Nope.
I'm acutely aware that there are many different types of interactions, dialogue styles and how people are perceived.
And after decades of talking with people, online and face to face, I'm no longer bothered with these differences.
Atheists clearly believe that they are right, and don't have to take the time to learn the truth until an argument arises that "convinces" them that they are wrong.
Numerous book titles have been posted on this forum and they've been summarily dismissed as irrelevant.
The problem here is that you're hoping that you don't have to decide based on your own beliefs.
You're on an internet forum which by the very concept that only 7% of any message you read is limited to 7% of the entire content of the message.
You have no way to get the 55% of body language, or the 38% of vocal intonation.
So, the lack of these two other components, which are the balance of the message, you impose your own bias, preconceptions, perhaps previous experiences from TV, or a church you may have attended at some point before.
So, since we're both limited, and you want to argue, instead of simply taking the time, you're placing yourself in the worst position.