NeutralSoundingName
Member
(I wrote X to keep the title shorter. X=Jewish/Christian)
Christians do a lot of leg work, trying to convince people that the Bible is true, but so many things work against them. Maybe it's not God's intention for people to be convinced by it. During a lot of tedious arguments, atheists may remember Christians retreating to "god won't show us proof, because that would take away our free will". This undermines the Bible, since they claim the Bible is proof.
Famous examples of how the Bible makes it hard to believe.
1. Sun created on 4th day. Surely it would have been better to have it created on the first day. Augustine didn't believe it, and neither did anyone prior. Genesis 2:4 is another attempt to do it right, but makes it worse. If this is the front of the Bible, then surely you want to make a good impression.
- humans created in God's image (really?)
- magic tree put in the wrong place
- deliberately-installed talking serpent, that tells the truth
- serpent somehow becomes Satan later, with no explanation
- Elohim and Yahwey seem to disagree on things
- God can't exterminate humans without asking a man to gather millions of species and put them in a boat, but has no trouble during passover
- God forgets to put plant species on the boat.
- Babel tower intimidates God, so he curses them with something they already had.
2. Hell. Create a disgusting idea to cudgel people into believing your religion, but don't explain anywhere, where it came from, or why. Make it look like it came from Greeks, rather than the Hebrew religion.. Avoid mentioning it in the whole Torah and Genesis. Put a really vague mention of hell on the end of Daniel, a book of prophecy which is supposedly locked up until the end of time. Put a load of prophecies in Daniel that don't happen, to make people think it's a fake, anyway. Put details of hell in the book of Enoch, but have Christians and Jews throw it out. Then make two versions of it, and leave it with Ethiopians.
3. Jesus.
- Insist that he died for our sins, but is still alive.
- In the main book of the NT, Matthew (last verse) - just say he resurrected for no particular reason, other than to show us he had power.
- Don't use the word "grace" in the entire gospel, esp. in Matthew don't even hint at how grace could save you.
- Let someone who murdered Christians and maybe never met any, dispense his words of contradictory wisdom
- Tell us to follow all Jewish law in Matthew, and all of Jesus' laws, and then say you don't have to.
- Don't let him write anything
- Don't put any authorship or dates on the books
4. Satan.
- create a nemesis to wreck it all up, but don't explain how God could possibly be almost losing, or give any sense of what Satan is.
- have a prophecy that only virgin men go to heaven
-
As you know, the list kind of goes on. My intent is not to have Christians defend any of these problems, but to simply ask: Do you think you've been given a hard book to work with, and if so, why? If not, then does that go against the empirical evidence?
Christians do a lot of leg work, trying to convince people that the Bible is true, but so many things work against them. Maybe it's not God's intention for people to be convinced by it. During a lot of tedious arguments, atheists may remember Christians retreating to "god won't show us proof, because that would take away our free will". This undermines the Bible, since they claim the Bible is proof.
Famous examples of how the Bible makes it hard to believe.
1. Sun created on 4th day. Surely it would have been better to have it created on the first day. Augustine didn't believe it, and neither did anyone prior. Genesis 2:4 is another attempt to do it right, but makes it worse. If this is the front of the Bible, then surely you want to make a good impression.
- humans created in God's image (really?)
- magic tree put in the wrong place
- deliberately-installed talking serpent, that tells the truth
- serpent somehow becomes Satan later, with no explanation
- Elohim and Yahwey seem to disagree on things
- God can't exterminate humans without asking a man to gather millions of species and put them in a boat, but has no trouble during passover
- God forgets to put plant species on the boat.
- Babel tower intimidates God, so he curses them with something they already had.
2. Hell. Create a disgusting idea to cudgel people into believing your religion, but don't explain anywhere, where it came from, or why. Make it look like it came from Greeks, rather than the Hebrew religion.. Avoid mentioning it in the whole Torah and Genesis. Put a really vague mention of hell on the end of Daniel, a book of prophecy which is supposedly locked up until the end of time. Put a load of prophecies in Daniel that don't happen, to make people think it's a fake, anyway. Put details of hell in the book of Enoch, but have Christians and Jews throw it out. Then make two versions of it, and leave it with Ethiopians.
3. Jesus.
- Insist that he died for our sins, but is still alive.
- In the main book of the NT, Matthew (last verse) - just say he resurrected for no particular reason, other than to show us he had power.
- Don't use the word "grace" in the entire gospel, esp. in Matthew don't even hint at how grace could save you.
- Let someone who murdered Christians and maybe never met any, dispense his words of contradictory wisdom
- Tell us to follow all Jewish law in Matthew, and all of Jesus' laws, and then say you don't have to.
- Don't let him write anything
- Don't put any authorship or dates on the books
4. Satan.
- create a nemesis to wreck it all up, but don't explain how God could possibly be almost losing, or give any sense of what Satan is.
- have a prophecy that only virgin men go to heaven
-
As you know, the list kind of goes on. My intent is not to have Christians defend any of these problems, but to simply ask: Do you think you've been given a hard book to work with, and if so, why? If not, then does that go against the empirical evidence?