Is the Spirit owned by all three members of the Trinity?

Biblican said:
You've been programmed by a doctrine that was invented by men. I came on here and gave you scriptures you haven't heard before.
Click to expand...
Photine said:
That's LITERALLY you.
Click to expand...
I do my own research and haven't been programmed by any one. I have no denomination and I am not a follower of man, only Jesus. You can't say that. The problem with all these cults is that all have a guru that tells them what to believe. I always get my doctrine directly from scripture.
 
Biblican said:
I do my own research and haven't been programmed by any one. I have no denomination and I am not a follower of man, only Jesus. You can't say that. The problem with all these cults is that all have a guru that tells them what to believe. I always get my doctrine directly from scripture.
Click to expand...
Photine, you must really be convicted. When I have confronted demons they laugh because they can't defend themselves when confronted by the truth. Go to bed.
 
johnny guitar said:
He IS God Himself.
Click to expand...
So you have three "Himselves" who are individually called God and collectively called God? God is both a "he" when referring to an individual member but collectively your God is a "they". Your view of God is like a team or group of three members in perfect unity, right? Does your view of God include three centers of self-consciousness?
 
Andreas said:
So you have three "Himselves" who are individually called God and collectively called God? God is both a "he" when referring to an individual member but collectively your God is a "they". Your view of God is like a team or group of three members in perfect unity, right? Does your view of God include three centers of self-consciousness?
Click to expand...
1 Tim 1:6
 
johnny guitar said:
He IS God Himself.
Click to expand...
He is God's Spirit not His person. The scriptures designate two elements associated with God's construction. He is referred to as both soul and spirit. The Holy Spirit is His spirit as Jesus said (Matthew 10:20). God's person directs the operation of His Spirit Psalm 104:30. The Spirit is God because the Spirit is His substance. God's person is His being and both elements are unified.
 
Biblican said:
The spirit is what gives the body life. it is the breath that gave life to the first Adam and we inherit from him.
Click to expand...

If you follow your theory straight through it is not consistent. Your definition of "spirit" appears to change. What I mean is that the bible says the Spirit of God and angels are rational beings whose substance is Spirit. Yet when you talk about the human spirit you mean a non-rational life force, breath. Not consistent.
 
Biblican said:
The Holy Spirit is God's Spirit as Jesus said Matthew 10:20. The Holy Spirit is God's substance, what He is. God's person is His being, who He is. The Spirit instigates creation at God's direction Psalm 104:30. God's person operates through His Spirit which enables Him to communicate with His creation. God's Spirit does not give the Father life, God is self-existent. The Spirit is life and is the life source of Jesus.
Click to expand...
On the contrary The Holy Spirit is not God Spirit as Jesus on account God is Spirit by His very Nature ,Hence it is Common Spiration .appropriated in a distinction/plurality of The Supposita of which it is spoken, which is expressed by way of Hypostasis. It follows , as The Father is Spiratio , The Son is Spiratio , and thus constituting a single Originating Principle of The Holy Spirit.

I said all that to say , you asserting" spirit is this and spirit is that", in no way NEGATE The Subsisting/Substantive Reality of One Person/Supposita/Hypostasis of The Father, another of The Son, and another of The Holy Spirit, signified by Trinity.

Hope that helps

....... Alan
 
aeg4971 said:
On the contrary The Holy Spirit is not God Spirit as Jesus on account God is Spirit by His very Nature ,Hence it is Common Spiration .appropriated in a distinction/plurality of The Supposita of which it is spoken, which is expressed by way of Hypostasis. It follows , as The Father is Spiratio , The Son is Spiratio , and thus constituting a single Originating Principle of The Holy Spirit.
Click to expand...

@aeg4971, do you consider @Biblican a Trinitarian?

If you can’t say No...

What would @Biblican have to say to make you consider him a Binitarian rather than a Trinitarian?
 
Andreas said:
Yes, just like Colossians 2:8. Viewing the eternal Godhead with earthly categories like "persons" is empty nonsense.
Click to expand...
But it's "only Theology", so no problem. When It comes to unknowables (like the complete nature of God), one "Term" is as good as another.
 
Biblican said:
He is God's Spirit not His person. The scriptures designate two elements associated with God's construction. He is referred to as both soul and spirit. The Holy Spirit is His spirit as Jesus said (Matthew 10:20). God's person directs the operation of His Spirit Psalm 104:30. The Spirit is God because the Spirit is His substance. God's person is His being and both elements are unified.
Click to expand...
The Holy Spirit is a PERSON, NOT a substance.
Substances do NOT conceive babies.
 
Bob Carabbio said:
But it's "only Theology", so no problem. When It comes to unknowables (like the complete nature of God), one "Term" is as good as another.
Click to expand...
You don't really believe that. Why not use the term whatchamacallit, then? You are not living on Mars hill with the statue to the unknown God. His name is JESUS, right?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top