No, this is not a straw man. This is the crux of the issue that you keep running away from. I know that you want to keep talking about belief that is based on reality, but no-one disagrees on that. The disagreement surrounds belief in something that is not reality. Until you acknowledge that such beliefs, whatever you want to call them, exist and are indistinguishable to the person who holds that belief from beliefs that are true, we cannot progress any discussion. You keep refusing to answer by throwing the term straw man. What you mean by straw man is " I'm not answering this because it blows my argument out of the water. " Well if it does, at least you have faced the truth, instead of spending your life running away from it.