Whatever claims - disease is evil

[Lighthearted Atheist]

Well can she prove it?
Where is her evidence? Where is her objective standard of evil?

Evil is human concept - it is an idea - it does not exist in reality. Evil is subjective to each of us like if something is good, tasty, just, or vile.

If someone said disease is evil then that means they find disease to be evil subjectively. There is nothing to prove since it is a human opinion, not an objective fact. You can believe that disease is awesome and you would not need to prove that - its your subjective opinion.

If you claim evil is objective then you are going to need to prove that.

You are confusing objective and subjective again.

 

[Electric Skeptic]

I know - atheists dont answer because they cant

Unsupported; you cannot evidence this claim.

 

[ferengi]

I missed one.

Avoiding the OP

 

[ferengi]

Can she prove what?

Her claims what else?

 

[ferengi]

Unsupported; you cannot evidence this claim.

Prove it

 

[ferengi]

Evil is human concept - it is an idea - it does not exist in reality. Evil is subjective to each of us like if something is good, tasty, just, or vile.

Your evidence is? Is this an objectively true statement?

 

[5wize]

LoL... ferengi rat-a-tat-tat... Must have just got out of jail... had it all pent up.

 

[ferengi]

LoL... ferengi rat-a-tat-tat... Must have just got out of jail... had it all pent up.

Still avoiding the OP

 

[Lighthearted Atheist]

Your evidence is? Is this an objectively true statement?

'Evil' is an adjective. It is the definition of the word. Something that is evil to someone might not be evil to someone else. That's how adjectives work.

And I really have no interest in debating definitions with you anymore. I'm still traumatized by our debate on the definition of atheism where you rejected the definition in your own link. I'd rather tilt windmills.

 

[ferengi]

'Evil' is an adjective. It is the definition of the word. Something that is evil to someone might not be evil to someone else. That's how adjectives work.

So you cant prove your claim.

I'm still traumatized by our debate on the definition of atheism where you rejected the definition in your own link. I'd rather tilt windmills.

Still posting false claims.

 

[Lighthearted Atheist]

So you cant prove your claim.

Most rational people accept the definition of the word as the....definition of the word. If you reject the definition then that's cool. Strange, but cool.

Still posting false claims.

Okie dokie. Have a great night. By great I mean to use the definition 'above the average'. I hope that does not throw you.

 

[ferengi]

Most rational people accept the definition of the word as the....definition of the word. If you reject the definition then that's cool. Strange, but cool.

So your cherry picking is what?

I notice you keep avoiding the OP as you must

 

[Lighthearted Atheist]

So your cherry picking is what?

I no longer even understand you.

I notice you keep avoiding the OP as you must

OK - you asked for an objective standard of evil. How do we measure evil if it is objective? For example, if I want to see if smoking weed is evil or not how would we objectively prove that?

 

[ferengi]

I no longer even understand you.

Nice avoidance.

OK - you asked for an objective standard of evil.

Correct.

How do we measure evil if it is objective?

OOPSS - FAIL - I asked for an objective standard of evil - instead you changed the subject with your burden shifting.

 

[Electric Skeptic]

Prove it

Your claim; the onus is no you. Christians never can support their claims.

 

[ferengi]

Your claim; the onus is no you. Christians never can support their claims.

Shifting the burden - unsupported claim - [projection.

 

[Electric Skeptic]

Shifting the burden - unsupported claim - [projection.

You made the claim, not me. The burden is all yours.

 

[Lighthearted Atheist]

OOPSS - FAIL - I asked for an objective standard of evil - instead you changed the subject with your burden shifting.

I cannot find an objective standard if evil anywhere. So I guess I can only provide the subjective standard. If you have an objective example I'd love to see it. If not then that's cool too.

 

[ferengi]

You made the claim, not me. The burden is all yours.

What claim?

 

[ferengi]

I cannot find an objective standard if evil anywhere.

Argument from ignorance - so therefore it does not exist? Where did you look? Are you looking in the right place?

So I guess I can only provide the subjective standard.

Which is a contradiction.

If you have an objective example I'd love to see it. If not then that's cool too.

Nice burden shifting.