Announcement

Collapse

Message to all users:

https://carm.org/forum-rules

Super Member Subscription
https://carm.org/carm-super-members-banner-ad-signup

As most of you are aware, we had a crash to forums and were down for over two days a while back. We did have to do an upgrade to the vbulletin software to fix the forums and that has created changes, VB no longer provide the hybrid or threaded forums. There are some issues/changes to the forums we are not able to fix or change. Also note the link address change, please let friends and posters know of the changed link to the forums. For now this is the only link available, https://forums.carm.org/vb5/ but if clicking on forum on carm.org homepage it will now send you to this link. (edited to add https: now working.

Again, we are working through some of the posting and viewing issues to learn how to post with the changes, you will have to check and test the different features, icons that have changed. You may also want to go to profile settings,since many of the notifications, information in profile, also to update/edit your avatar by clicking on avatar space, pull down arrow next to login for user settings.

Edit to add "How to read forums, to make it easier."
Pull down arrow next to login name upper right select profile, or user settings when page opens to profile,select link in tab that says Account. Then select/choose options, go down to Conversation Detail Options, Select Display mode Posts, NOT Activity, that selection of Posts will make the pages of discussions go to last post on last page rather than out of order that happens if you choose activity threads. Then be sure to go to bottom and select SAVE Changes in your profile options. You can then follow discussions by going through the pages, to the last page having latest responses. Then click on the other links Privacy, Notifications, to select viewing options,the forums get easier if you open all the tabs or links in your profile, user settings and select options. To join Super Member, pull down arrow next to login name, select User Settings and then click on tab/link at top that says Subscriptions.

Thank you for your patience and God Bless.

Diane S
https://carm.org/forum-rules
See more
See less

What are some of the challenges y'all are facing as parents (or kids)?

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • What are some of the challenges y'all are facing as parents (or kids)?

    Hi, folks. I wanted to start a conversation to find out what parents and kids are struggling with recently. I'd like to help, if I could.

    Blessings,
    George

  • Josheb
    replied
    Originally posted by Enilorac View Post
    There is no "single" thing...it's 18 years of teaching and training in many different things to make a reasonably self-sufficient, independent adult. But, what would I know...I only raised three of 'em.
    That is incorrect .

    It is incorrect because there is one preeminent thing upon which all else will be built.

    It is incorrect because to pit the "one thing" against the additional 18-20 years of training and teaching is a false dichotomy. They work together, not in exclusion of one another.

    It is incorrect because personal anecdotal experience is just that.

    It is incorrect because reasonable self-sufficient, independent adult is not the goal. It is, in fact, a problem to be solved (and I suspect if I told you what a better objective was you'd agree, smack palm to forehead and say, "Yes, of course, that's what I meant!").

    It is incorrect because neither "reasonably self-sufficient" and independence nor the correct objective are not measured by good jobs, monetary income, and marriage (and I suspect you know this, too.).


    And why anyone would think it appropriate to call someone they've never met condescending based on a single post is a problem, one that doesn't work in your favor if the goal is to persuade and prove your position. It's an internet discussion board. It's not personal.


    There is one thing that is preeminent. Everything else will be built upon it. Or not.

    Leave a comment:


  • Enilorac
    replied
    Originally posted by Josheb View Post
    There is a single most important thing for any two parents to strive for in their endeavor to parent. The statement, "There's no SINGLE thing..." is incorrect and it doesn't take any condescension to say so.
    There is no "single" thing...it's 18 years of teaching and training in many different things to make a reasonably self-sufficient, independent adult. But, what would I know...I only raised three of 'em.

    Leave a comment:


  • Josheb
    replied
    Originally posted by Enilorac View Post
    I'm sorry I didn't answer the question to YOUR satisfaction or expectation... And, do NOT point out things in that extremely condescending way.
    There is a single most important thing for any two parents to strive for in their endeavor to parent. The statement, "There's no SINGLE thing..." is incorrect and it doesn't take any condescension to say so.

    Leave a comment:


  • Mod8
    replied
    NOTE

    Address the issues, posters, and do not attack others especially if they do not live up to your expectations. I do note that there are posters who are close to bickering, so I urge all to be careful not to cause offense, and to not take offence if there seems to be one there. Seek clarification first before jumping to erroneous conclusions.

    Leave a comment:


  • Enilorac
    replied
    I'm sorry I didn't answer the question to YOUR satisfaction or expectation...
    edit...
    Last edited by CARM Admin; 04-29-18, 10:19 PM. Reason: send alerts/do not comment on the person

    Leave a comment:


  • Josheb
    replied
    Originally posted by Enilorac View Post
    I'm not George...but I have three functioning, successful adult children.

    First thing...teach them respect. Respect for themselves, respect for others, for their home, for their belongings.
    Second...as they get older, loosen the reins. Give them more and more responsibility. By 18 they should be pretty self-sufficient.
    Teach them how the world works.
    How to open a bank account, apply for a credit card, loan
    How to file taxes
    How to budget
    All you say is good and true but it is not what is the single most important thing parents can do to raise healthily functional children?
    Originally posted by Enilorac View Post
    There's no SINGLE thing...
    That is incorrect. Christ is a single thing. Everything else parents will do is built on that single critical aspect of existence. I cited another. Everything you just posted will be built on that critical aspect of parenting. Having one preeminent aspect does not preclude a "cascade;" a "cascade" must be built on something.

    Do you realize success was just defined by marriage and a certain level of employment?

    And I doubt anyone here want's to engage in comparative parenting based on the post hoc evidence of whether or not the kids turned out okay.

    Leave a comment:


  • Enilorac
    replied
    Originally posted by Josheb View Post

    Let me ask you, George, (after Jesus) what is the single most important thing parents can do to raise healthily functional children?
    I'm not George...but I have three functioning, successful adult children.

    First thing...teach them respect. Respect for themselves, respect for others, for their home, for their belongings.
    Second...as they get older, loosen the reins. Give them more and more responsibility. By 18 they should be pretty self-sufficient.
    Teach them how the world works.
    How to open a bank account, apply for a credit card, loan
    How to file taxes
    How to budget

    There's no SINGLE thing...it's a cascade as they get older. We saw parenting as a time-limited job. We had 18 years to produce functioning adults who were able to make their way in the world. We were rather successful. Oldest is a wife, mom, IT professional and freelance Graphic Designer. #2 is an Army Veteran, currently chief of security for a company, husband and father. #3 is a journeyman electrician (makes more $$ than the other two combined), husband and father.

    Leave a comment:


  • Josheb
    replied
    Bluemayskye, if I may...


    Try asking your daughter why it's the best or worst day ever. Start by repeating her own words back to her in the form of a question, "This is the best day ever?" maybe emphasizing the "ever." Let her hear what she sounds like.

    Your daughter is reaching an age where her brain is developing new structures and abilities (boys are a year or more behind, typically). Prior to age 8-10 children are limited to a fairly ego-centric manner of processing information but as they age they develop altruistic and abstract faculties.

    Realize that in all parenting challenges we're usually also dealing with deficits in our own faculties because parenting is constantly new terrain and few of us know what to do the first time something new comes up.

    Remember childhood is one big experiment for the child. S/he doesn't have the faintest clue what they're doing, what the should be thinking or feeling, or doing in response to any of it. And the problem is the folly bound in the heart of the child. The delight is that God made them creatures of exploration.

    Consider two foundational experiences:

    The first has to do with the little child who is, for example, drawing with crayons on the wall. Mom (or dad) walks in the room, gasps, and asks "What are you doing? What is wrong with you?!?!"



    The child is just doing what children do s/he has no idea there's anything wrong with it until the rhetorical question is asked. Young children do not understand rhetoric. Now consider the question, "What is wrong with you?" They take you at your word and assume something is wrong with them. The literally look at themselves and attempt a little inventory. Not finding anything wrong they look up and say, "I don't know," to which the parent begins the disciplinary process (making the child clean the wall or go to their room, etc.). From the child's perspective they've just learned three things: 1) there is something wrong with them, 2) they don't know what it is, and 3) no one's telling them.

    This is one of the way shame is seeded in a child.

    The second is the child a few years older running to first base after hitting the ball in the community t-ball league. The child stumbles and doesn't make it to first base. S/he gets up knees scratched and bleeding,the child feels physical pain, the embarrassment causes emotional pain, the knowledge that s/he failed to make it to base and let down his/her team mates causes cognitive duress, and it all happens suddenly in the time it takes for electrical impulses to cross neural synapses.

    The coach and maybe dad or mom run onto the field and touch the sore spot, look at the knee and say something along the lines of, "Aw, it's not that bad, you'll be fine. Don't cry." or if it's a boy he might hear, "Zuck it up, it's not that bad." In those few second the parent has just unwittingly and unintentionally sent a pile of messages to the child. The child heard, "My pain doesn't matter" or "My physical pain isn't real. My emotions can't be trusted, and neither can my thoughts."

    The child does feel all right but has just been told s/he is alright.

    This is an example of how children learn to tune out, first from their own experience, and eventually from the report of others.


    So here's what to do: Let the child speak. Let the child have his or her experience. Let them tell you of their physical pain, their fear or their lack of knowledge and their embarrassment fearing and not knowing. Reassure the child that what they are thinking feeling emotionally and feeling physically is understandable. Maybe even tell them of a time when you were little and felt similarly (not the "same way"). Then if correction or change is warranted ask them what they think they should do about it, and then when they have voiced their idea(s) gie them an alternative. "Let's try this....." or "Have you thought about....."

    Remember that during the first few years you are training the child for the middle years and during the middle years you are training the child for the tween and teen years and during the teen years you are teaching the teen to prepare for adulthood. A grade schooler does not process information the way a middle schooler does and a middle schooler does not do so the way a teenager does. Parents must adapt training to the change faculties of each developmental stage.

    Generally speaking: don't place too much emphasis on the first words out of a child's mouth. Keep them talking by supporting them because they'll tell you what they need. This is especially so in the teen years where the first words out f the teen's mouth is invariably inane. Keep them talking and two things will happen: 1) they'll make a little more sense, and 2) they'll get to the real issue, and maybe.... 3) a teachable place where they will receive your input.

    None of it will happen of the parent child relationship isn't good.

    So, Blue, keep your daughter talking. Give her alternatives such as, "Hmmm... yes, that does sound bad," or "Yes, that does sound frightening," or "That does sound like your friend wasn't sharing."

    Remember also: we are training our children to select their future mate. This is one of the reasons why having a good marriage is preeminent. The child watches parents model husbanding and wifing, and s/he does it for 18-20 years without any ability to critically examine it in the early years. The mother/daughter relationship models how she handles herself as a woman, the father daughter relationship how she will relate to her own husband, what she will expect of him and how to manage some very complex relational aspects of adulthood.

    Your daughter's behavior is normal. She's experimenting with "best" and worst" and comparatives. Help her.
    "Let no unwholesome word proceed from your mouth, but only such a word as is good for edification according to the need of the moment... (Eph. 4:29)
    "The soothing tongue is a tree of life" (Pr. 15: 4)
    "To answer before listening ó that is folly and shame... From the fruit of their mouth a personís stomach is filled;with the harvest of their lips they are satisfied. The tongue has the power of life and death, and those who love it will eat its fruit." (Pr. 18:13, 20-21)
    "Understand this, my dear [parents]: You must all be quick to listen, slow to speak, and slow to get angry."
    "Do nothing from rivalry or conceit, but in humility count others more significant than yourselves. Let each of you look not only to his own interests, but also to the interests of others." (Phil. 2:3-4 ESV)
    Works for parenting, too.
    Last edited by Josheb; 04-10-18, 11:42 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Josheb
    replied
    Originally posted by gelacy View Post
    Hi, Josheb. I'm not offended in the least. I'll write more with regards to some of your questions, although it seemed like some were more thought-provoking than anything else. Still, I'll have a little background work done soon, as it is relevant; to "the internet" I'm just a dude with a keyboard.
    That is the attitude that should be communicated (Phil. 2:3) and it's hard to do i a text-based medium where folks will assign motive.
    Originally posted by gelacy View Post
    But with regards to the question you asked, I'd recommend Thomas Watson's "The Doctrine of Repentance." Watson does a wonderful job of not only explaining what false repentance looks like but also like what genuine repentance looks.
    Wow. Old school. Between-the-lines-response. I'd like to explore its relevance to parenting, and the disciplining of children, but the question was another "trick" question. What do you think of these two ideas:

    1) You should have an answer to the question, but do so knowing that no single book on parenting is sufficient or wholly correct. The problem is too big to address in a single tome and they all make some error somewhere.

    2) the best "book" is another couple who is going through the same things with you. Or maybe two couples: one that's older and has negotiated the process reasonably successfully and another couple more peer oriented with whom the two of you can share your joys and commiserate with you when things are tough.

    Can you see those as valid and efficacious answers to the person that asks that question, the parent who is asking the wrong question?
    Originally posted by gelacy View Post
    It's easy to allow ourselves to fall into a trap of "Well, he said he was sorry" and think we've rooted out the true issues and that our little angel is genuinely sorry. I think that Watson's little book can do wonders for parents in ways beyond the spiritual ramifications.

    From a modern author I'd suggest "Parenting by God's Promises" by Joel Beeke. He does good work laying out the covenantal foundation for parenting and setting clear duties for parents of children of all ages, up to and including the ones in your illustration.
    lol! You really are a Presby!

    I'm encouraged you have an answer (and equally encouraged by your tolerance with my methods). The question was asked to highlight the problem with the question. There's nothing wrong with parenting books but they're all flawed in some way so the best parent is reading more than one and adapting the information to their unique spawn (Pr. 22:6), but the best sources are others.
    Life functions on relationships.
    Relationships function on goals, boundaries, and expectations.
    If you don't know where you want to go and don't know how to get there... you won't.

    Parenting is a relationship.

    It takes at least two healthy relationships to have one healthy relationship.

    Core principles.


    I don't expect answers to all those rhetorical questions, George. They were mainly rhetorical devices for the sake of the exchange (although I do think you should be prepared for real-life examples).



    Let me trade places with you. I'm no expert. Got only half as many kids as you (but they are older and on their way out). I'm a professional counselor but I don't work with kids younger than 15. Been in-lay ministry for 30 years, mentored many men from childhood to adulthood, boyhood to manhood. Any questions for me?

    Leave a comment:


  • gelacy
    replied
    Hi, Josheb. I'm not offended in the least. I'll write more with regards to some of your questions, although it seemed like some were more thought-provoking than anything else. Still, I'll have a little background work done soon, as it is relevant; to "the internet" I'm just a dude with a keyboard.

    But with regards to the question you asked, I'd recommend Thomas Watson's "The Doctrine of Repentance." Watson does a wonderful job of not only explaining what false repentance looks like but also like what genuine repentance looks.

    It's easy to allow ourselves to fall into a trap of "Well, he said he was sorry" and think we've rooted out the true issues and that our little angel is genuinely sorry. I think that Watson's little book can do wonders for parents in ways beyond the spiritual ramifications.

    From a modern author I'd suggest "Parenting by God's Promises" by Joel Beeke. He does good work laying out the covenantal foundation for parenting and setting clear duties for parents of children of all ages, up to and including the ones in your illustration.

    Blessings,
    George

    Leave a comment:


  • Josheb
    replied
    Originally posted by gelacy View Post
    Be married first. Then, work together to deal with problems and stay married.

    If I'm reading your context clues correctly.
    Excellent! Now you're on the right track. The single best thing any two parents can do for their children to help them be healthily functional adults is to have a healthy marriage.


    I don't mean to sound like I'm shaking my finger at you, George, but folks come into CARM openly stating they are here to tell others this or that. They are rarely good sources for anything other than object lessons on how not to believe, think, ad live.

    Maybe you're different. I hope so.

    Start with James 3:1,
    "Let not many of you become teachers, my brethren, knowing that as such we will incur a stricter judgment."
    If you can manage that you'll already have started off better than most.

    I know you have four children, but the oldest looks to be about 7 or 8. What is it you can tell me or the other parents of teens? You're 44 and have been a pastor for 10+/- years, so what can you tell those of use who ten-15 years on you and have spent a 30-40 years working within the body of Christ helping others? What can you tell the old among us who've mentored men and women for three or four decades? What would you tell the one being mentored without undermining the mentor who has fasted and prayed over that person soliciting cyber-advice from a stranger?

    What preparation from God have you gone through to empower you to come into CARM and teach others how to raise their kids? Have you been raised in Pharaoh's house to prepare you for the multicultrual politics of the world? Perhaps your military service did provide you some wisdom here. Have you been sent into exile to wander in the wilderness and so learn of yourself, your limits, and your dependencies? Were you sent to another for tutelage to yourself be mentored, being built in the image of a successful practitioner of parenting so as to build others in your image with the image of Christ the common theme running through all your disparate personalities, strengths, and weaknesses?

    Do you understand that many soliciting advice from you will walk away the instance you fail to correctly answer the simplest and most foundational of inquiries? They will not place any confidence in the answers of those who can't do the basics.

    What trials have you children endured? What can you tell the parent of a one year old who continuously vomits because of a birth defect? What can you tell that parent whose first born is on the spectrum (do you know what that is?), and the second born has Bluemayskye's challenges? What can you do for the mother who has learned genetic abnormality is the likely cause for all three of these conditions? She's birthed three seemingly imperfect children and their "defects" are entirely attributable to her and something about which she was ignorant and cannot fix. What do you do with the husband and father just back from Afghanistan who tells you, "I didn't ask for this"?


    Let me reiterate: I am not saying you cannot, should not, or are not supposed to do this, but I am asking you some important questions.

    If you want a "ministry" advising parents you should at least be confident of this calling because it would be better for you to be thrown into the sea with a millstone tied around your neck than to cause one of God's little ones to stumble.



    Forgive my bluntness. I mean to be direct, not disrespectful.




    Here's another question for you: A parent asks you what is the best book (beside the Bible) for them to read to help them discipline their children and all their children are under say 10 or 12 (not teenagers). What do you recommend?

    Leave a comment:


  • gelacy
    replied
    Be married first. Then, work together to deal with problems and stay married.

    If I'm reading your context clues correctly.

    Leave a comment:


  • Josheb
    replied
    Originally posted by gelacy View Post
    OK, Josheb. I didn't realize that that was what you meant by "(after Jesus)." Sorry about that.

    I would say that other that teaching the Gospel I would say that going deeper into Scripture from a systematic perspective will cover major issues facing young people. For example, the respective doctrines of God and man put people into their proper places, which can keep people from emphasizing their own urges and desires over and against that of God's desires for them. There are other core doctrines of the faith that can be taught and then applied to a child's specific situation.

    In my experience as a minister and counselor most of the causes of issues within families come from a fundamental ignorance of basic Christian doctrine. They might get the "you're a sinner and Jesus died for sinners" right but there is so much more to the faith than that, things that have real world applications to modern issues of identity, "self-esteem," vocation and calling in life, personality issues, etc. Too often, people want to deal with symptoms with a quick verse or two, not realizing that they've missed a huge chance to delve deeper into the Bible with their kids in a what that, had they taken advantage of it, would have given them the solution to the much deeper problem.

    I'm not sure what you're trying to draw out of me, though. You might have an answer to this that I'm just missing.

    Blessings,
    George
    Okay, let me try this another way. Let Christ go.

    AFTER CHRIST...... What is the single most important thing parents can do to raise healthily functional children?

    What is the best thing any two parents can do, regardless of whether or not they are Christians, what is THE most important thing any two parents can do to raise healthy functional parents.



    I respectfully submit to you, George, that if this one thing is not correctly understood then it disqualifies you and anyone else failing to understand this from assuming a position of counsel or advisor on the topic of parenting. What I am asking is foundational and universal and you should already know it. Not only should this truth be known but the question inquiring about it should be instantly recognized when asked.

    If you don't get it on your own, you're gonna face palm when I tell you.



    What is the single most important thing parents can do to raise healthily functional children? What is the best thing any two parents can do, regardless of whether or not they are Christians, what is THE most important thing any two parents can do to raise healthy functional parents.

    Leave a comment:


  • gelacy
    replied
    OK, Josheb. I didn't realize that that was what you meant by "(after Jesus)." Sorry about that.

    I would say that other that teaching the Gospel I would say that going deeper into Scripture from a systematic perspective will cover major issues facing young people. For example, the respective doctrines of God and man put people into their proper places, which can keep people from emphasizing their own urges and desires over and against that of God's desires for them. There are other core doctrines of the faith that can be taught and then applied to a child's specific situation.

    In my experience as a minister and counselor most of the causes of issues within families come from a fundamental ignorance of basic Christian doctrine. They might get the "you're a sinner and Jesus died for sinners" right but there is so much more to the faith than that, things that have real world applications to modern issues of identity, "self-esteem," vocation and calling in life, personality issues, etc. Too often, people want to deal with symptoms with a quick verse or two, not realizing that they've missed a huge chance to delve deeper into the Bible with their kids in a what that, had they taken advantage of it, would have given them the solution to the much deeper problem.

    I'm not sure what you're trying to draw out of me, though. You might have an answer to this that I'm just missing.

    Blessings,
    George

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X